A New Spin on an Age Old Question.

[Koltreg]

(08-24-2011 11:38 AM)Classy Viking Wrote:  Okay so how about: Matt Fraction Vs Brian K. Vaughan?

I'd go with Fraction over Vaughn. Fraction seems more wiley and his baseball knowledge would probably give him the ability to fight with a bat. Vaugh seems like more of a slow wear the opponent down fighter as well.

[Classy Viking]

(08-24-2011 11:43 AM)Koltreg Wrote:  

(08-24-2011 11:38 AM)Classy Viking Wrote:  Okay so how about: Matt Fraction Vs Brian K. Vaughan?

I'd go with Fraction over Vaughn. Fraction seems more wiley and his baseball knowledge would probably give him the ability to fight with a bat. Vaugh seems like more of a slow wear the opponent down fighter as well.

I don't know, Fraction would come in with some fast swings, but Vaughan is more of a heavy hitter, I think it could go either way really.

[cyclopsfan1]

(08-24-2011 11:46 AM)Classy Viking Wrote:  

(08-24-2011 11:43 AM)Koltreg Wrote:  

(08-24-2011 11:38 AM)Classy Viking Wrote:  Okay so how about: Matt Fraction Vs Brian K. Vaughan?

I'd go with Fraction over Vaughn. Fraction seems more wiley and his baseball knowledge would probably give him the ability to fight with a bat. Vaugh seems like more of a slow wear the opponent down fighter as well.

I don't know, Fraction would come in with some fast swings, but Vaughan is more of a heavy hitter, I think it could go either way really.

Fraction would start out with an intense and amazing first round but with each subsequent round, Fraction's fight quality begins declining to the point where Fraction is just stumbling around the ring blindly swinging away. Also his fighting style will be either bland or it will lift heavily from far better fighters.

Vaughn starts out slow but finishes amazingly. He would knock out Fraction in the later rounds as Fraction is busy stumbling around the ring.

How about:

Dan Slott vs Dan Abnett & Andy Lanning in an handicap match

[Mr. X]

The Brand New Day brain trust vs. the 52 brain trust.

(Assume Mark Waid defects from 52 to Spider-Man during a LIVE Pay-Per-View event)

[MisterSmith]

(08-24-2011 12:09 PM)cyclopsfan1 Wrote:  Fraction would start out with an intense and amazing first round but with each subsequent round, Fraction's fight quality begins declining to the point where Fraction is just stumbling around the ring blindly swinging away. Also his fighting style will be either bland or it will lift heavily from far better fighters.

Are you just talking about his presumed fighting style or are you implying something?

[cyclopsfan1]

(08-24-2011 01:44 PM)Mr. X Wrote:  The Brand New Day brain trust vs. the 52 brain trust.

(Assume Mark Waid defects from 52 to Spider-Man during a LIVE Pay-Per-View event)

52 Brain Trust due to a numbers game. Just far more of them.

(08-24-2011 01:45 PM)MisterSmith Wrote:  

(08-24-2011 12:09 PM)cyclopsfan1 Wrote:  Fraction would start out with an intense and amazing first round but with each subsequent round, Fraction's fight quality begins declining to the point where Fraction is just stumbling around the ring blindly swinging away. Also his fighting style will be either bland or it will lift heavily from far better fighters.

Are you just talking about his presumed fighting style or are you implying something?

I might be implying something.

[Classy Viking]

The 52 team has both Grant Morrison's transdimensional shaman magic and the pure wild man that is Keith Griffen. Brand New day hasn't a pray.

[MisterSmith]

(08-24-2011 01:51 PM)cyclopsfan1 Wrote:  I might be implying something.

Heh, as someone who no longer reads anything he writes, I know what you mean.

I was going to suggest Warren Ellis vs. anybody, but I then realized the man has a combination of cigarettes, alcohol and/or red bull on him at all times. It just wouldn't be fair to anyone else.

[Steve!]

(08-24-2011 11:46 AM)Classy Viking Wrote:  

(08-24-2011 11:43 AM)Koltreg Wrote:  

(08-24-2011 11:38 AM)Classy Viking Wrote:  Okay so how about: Matt Fraction Vs Brian K. Vaughan?

I'd go with Fraction over Vaughn. Fraction seems more wiley and his baseball knowledge would probably give him the ability to fight with a Butt. Vaugh seems like more of a slow wear the opponent down fighter as well.

I don't know, Fraction would come in with some fast swings, but Vaughan is more of a heavy hitter, I think it could go either way really.

You know, from that one issue of Ex Machina and various interviews, I'm fairly certain Vaughan doesn't know how to throw a punch.

[Name]

Morr v Mill: Morrison
BKF v The Fractionator: Fraction. All the research he did for Immortal Iron Fist musta worn off on him
BvS:GJ: Superman.